This midterm election, Initiative 638 passed in a statewide referendum in Washington State, requiring girls in youth sports to prove “biological sex” (assigned sex at birth), both within the public school system and the private school system. Although King County, the most populous county in Washington including Seattle, voted no, nearly every other county in the state with the exception of Whatcom and Jefferson had a majority vote for Initiative 638.
The method of determination of the assigned sex at birth of the young athletes is not specified beyond being “by a healthcare provider,” but is implied to require a physical exam of the child’s genitals by a healthcare provider. Although other methods such as genetic testing have been promoted, these would cost parents several thousand dollars and require specialists to administer at all, with most methods of determining reproductive sex outside of complex genetic testing requiring physical examination. The initiative has been challenged in court by a coalition of nonprofits and families including the ACLU.
If it goes into effect the measure will impact a great many young people. Nearly every single school district in Washington State has youth sports programs, and many private programs exist as well for everything from baseball to flag football to field hockey. According to the National Survey of Children’s Health, in 2024 this was just under 300,000 girls of varying ages.
Alyssa, a mother in Seattle, has a transgender daughter who is 7 years old and enrolled in the local elementary school. Assigned Media conducted an interview with Alyssa via email after sending her a message on social media. The child is open about being trans and reportedly has an accepting environment at school, but is also aware of transphobia in the world including the recent referendum. Alyssa described her child as well adjusted and resilient for her age. “The fact that she’s surrounded by a lot of people who hate her on principle is unfortunately not news to her. She’s sad but she’s not letting it take her down and she’s definitely not changing anything about herself because of it.”
In order to enroll a child in youth sports across most youth sports programs in Washington State, a birth certificate was already required- this has been longstanding as a rule in most programs in Alyssa’s area. However, this system did not disenfranchise trans individuals per se- because Washington State as well as other states allows for the amending of a birth certificate’s gender marker by a parent or legal guardian, it was possible for a trans girl to play anyway. This is now impossible. (Alyssa’s daughter has never been enrolled in youth sports and is not particularly interested, in part due to existing hostility from parents and organizations to trans girls’ participation.)
The majority of the youth sports at elementary age are private programs designed to teach children sports and are not officially endorsed by the school district, though the school district does provide middle school and high school sports which are covered in the newsletter. Seattle Public Schools also voted to take legal action to oppose I-638 a few days after the legislation passed and was described by Alyssa as supportive to her child and progressive on trans issues as a whole.
Earlier this year the Washington Interscholastic Activities Association estimated that there were a total of 5-10 transgender athletes participating in youth sports statewide, according to local reporting.
Over the weekend, a weekly newsletter written by Seattle Public Schools superintendent Ben Shuldiner announced that Seattle Public Schools was joining the lawsuit to protect its students. The superintendent added “I, as the Superintendent, have a moral and ethical duty to protect, defend, love and support all our students. Their rights are just as sacrosanct as our rights. Their privacy, their human agency, and their humanity need to be privileged and loved.”
Several Washington residents who voted no on Initiative 638, primarily in King County, contacted Assigned Media to express their opinions on Initiative 638 and the voting results. “I really didn’t expect it to actually pass and the optimistic part of me has to wonder if some people just misread it or something” said Rowan, a voter in their 20s in King County, adding “This is not only harmful to trans girls but all trans people and also cis girls since they will be the majority of athletes subjected to these invasive procedures.”
Another voter, a 20 year old also in King County, said “I am profoundly disappointed in this morally bankrupt country” and expressed severe concern for transgender Washingtonians. “Even excluding the shittiness of genital exams for girls, it doesn’t care if a girl wants to play on a boy’s team. It’s hypocritical and discriminatory.” said a 25 year old Snohomish County voter who voted no. A 29 year old in Thurston County who voted no held similar sentiments and also noted “It’s probably dead on arrival due to being unconstitutional in Washington, so the whole thing is a waste of taxpayer dollars.”
The constitutionality of Initiative 638 has not been determined in the judiciary system yet. In an online public statement, Washington Democratic Party Shasti Conrad stated a belief that Initiative 638 is unconstitutional and added “Washington Democrats support our trans family members, neighbors, and community and we will never abandon the belief that everyone deserves to be accepted for who they are and provided with opportunities to thrive. “
Adi Kung is a journalist, writer and poet. She currently resides in New York.





